Developer knowledge network · moderated exchange

Społeczność UnreliableCode

Badania programistów, inżynieria wsteczna i społeczność programistów

Knowledge indexNa żywo
4Categories
919Threads
2.8KPosty
Analysis

Comparing Ghidra Decompiler vs Hex-Rays AST optimization pipelines

ida_ast_hacker
Microcode Dev
MEMBER
Rozpustnik: 74
Data dołączenia: Nov 2022
Posty: 6
Dzięki: 48
3 tygodnie temu · Aug 2, 2026 4:43 PM
#1

Deep comparison of decompiler internals:

  • Ghidra: Converts native assembly into high-level P-Code SSA (Static Single Assignment) form, applies graph simplification, and reconstructs control flow using an open architecture.
  • Hex-Rays (IDA Pro): Translates assembly into multi-tiered Microcode (mcode), executes over 20 optimization passes (type propagation, dead register elimination, loop normalization), and outputs a C-tree AST.

Hex-Rays produces tighter struct field access dereferences, while Ghidra excels at cross-architecture flexibility.

ghidra_fanatic
RE Specialist
MEMBER
Rozpustnik: 101
Data dołączenia: Mar 2019
Posty: 16
Dzięki: 14
3 tygodnie temu · Aug 2, 2026 8:21 PM
#2

Both are remarkable engineering achievements. Having Ghidra free for the community pushed the entire industry forward.

vtable_slayer
Senior Reverser
MEMBER
Rozpustnik: 215
Data dołączenia: Mar 2018
Posty: 86
Dzięki: 61
2 tygodnie temu · Aug 3, 2026 10:45 AM
#3

Great architectural comparison.